ABOUT THE VARIOUS TECHNOLOGIES
The spectra in this page were obtained using the methods found here:
Build a Spectroscope
How different lights change the appearance of colors in a box of 64 Crayola® crayons:
The Crayon Trials
|
INCANDESCENT LAMPS
Spectrum: |
|
The problems:
- The law requires the manufacture of old-style bulbs to end.
- The biggest problem with the incandescent lamp is that increasing the efficiency (which the law requires)
shortens its life. Halogen technology (see below) improves this somewhat, but adds some of its own problems.
- Another problem with incandescent lamps is that they are usually restricted to low color temperatures. Color
temperature changes with bulb wattage. Bulb coatings are used on some products to raise the color temperature.
While these still produce a continuous spectrum, the spectral response has a notch in it.
- Dimming changes color temperature
The biggest problem with the ban is that it leaves some uses with nothing to replace burned-out lamps with.
These uses include:
- Fixtures the new lightbulbs will not physically fit into
- Fixtures that can not take the extra heat of a halogen bulb
- Bulbs that need ventilation, and can't be put into an enclosed fixture.
- Hostile environments that would cause new technology bulbs to fail quickly (oven, freezer, etc.)
- Outdoor uses (often prohibited in the instructions of new technology bulbs)
- Touch lamps (won't light, blink the new lamps, or greatly shorten the lives of new lamps)
- Motion detector security fixtures (won't light, blink the new lamps, get stuck on, or drastically shorten
the lives of new lamps)
- Dimmers (won't light, blink the new lamps, dimming is not smooth, flickering, or greatly shorten the lives
of new lamps)
- Stage lighting and light show devices (won't light, blink the new lamps, or drastically shorten the lives
of new lamps)
- The need for a concentrated light source for focused lighting or projection equipment
- Photometry and colorimetry equipment need a flat spectral curve
- The need for a flat continuous spectrum for scientific purposes (none of the currently sold new
technologies provide this)
- The need for accurate visual color identification (none of the currently sold new technologies provide
this)
- The need to visually match colors made through different processes accurately
- An artist's need for balanced light to create art with
- An artistic need for balanced light for interior decorating purposes
- Electronic devices that use the current-limiting properties of incandescent filaments as ballasting loads
(at least one guitar amp)
- Various devices (e.g. incubators) and toys (e.g. the Easy Bake Oven) that use certain light bulbs as
controlled heat sources
- Users of the techniques outlined below to make other bulbs work with old equipment need old bulbs for the
loads
Using incandescent lamps as loads to keep old devices working with other kinds of lamps:
- For a load for a device feeding other kinds of lamps, connect two lamps of twice the wattage of one of
the typical lamps in series. They won't burn out.
- Keep a few spares in case of breakage. Buy them now. Halogen lamps might work, but they might not.
Techniques to get around the problems:
- Techniques that adapt the new lamps (but some require some old technology lamps to work) are listed
under each new type of lamp.
- If the lamp is a load in an electronic device, connecting two lamps of twice the wattage in series might
work. They won't burn out. But the temperature coefficient curve might not be the same.
- Replacing fixtures is an expensive solution to bulbs that won't fit or work in old fixtures.
|
HALOGEN LAMPS
Spectrum: |
|
The problems:
- The major problem with halogen bulbs is heat. Too often, the fixture can't take the heat from the
replacement bulb.
- One solution is expensive: replace the fixture.
- Another solution is to replace a Bakelite or plastic lamp socket with a porcelain socket.
- Reduce the wattage of the bulb.
- Use in a high temperature environment will shorten life.
- Lamp fails quickly if outside surface is contaminated (only exposed quartz tube lamps).
- Color temperature changes with wattage.
- Dimming changes color temperature
|
OLD TECHNOLOGY FLUORESCENT LAMPS
Spectrum: |
|
The problems:
- The biggest problem is size. An old-style fluorescent lamp will not fit into the space taken by the
incandescent lamp it is replacing
- The government has also banned the T-12 fluorescents, necessitating replacing these fixtures when the
bulbs burn out.
- If a dimmer was used, it will have to be removed, or replaced with a special system designed for
fluorescent lamps.
- Some remote control and timer systems work if one incandescent lamp is still on the circuit. Use the
load technique above.
- Can't be used in hostile environments.
- Cold environments cause early failure. Enclosing the fixture helps.
- Touch lamps are out of the question.
- Motion detector security systems drastically shorten lamp life. Do not use.
- Not a concentrated light source.
- The light curve is not flat. It is usually somewhat flat, with bright-line spikes in it. This is better
than new technology bulbs.
- Can not provide a flat continuous spectrum for scientific purposes.
- See below for scientific, color identification, matching, and artistry solutions.
- Provides many different colors and tints for interior decorating purposes.
- Will not work for electronic devices that use incandescent filaments as ballasting loads.
- Useless as a heat source.
- Contains mercury, which scares Democrats to death.
- Color temperature is determined by the phosphor mix.
|
COMPACT FLUORESCENT LAMPS (CFL) - PHOSPHOR
The problems:
- Will not physically fit some fixtures. Often the screw shell is recessed too far. Try an outlet tap
screw shell adapter.
- Most burn out faster if inside enclosed indoor fixtures.
- Can't be used in hostile environments.
- Outdoor uses might work if the fixture is enclosed.
- Touch lamps might work if one incandescent lamp load is still connected.
- Motion detector security fixtures drastically shorten the lives of these.
- Dimmers require a dimmable bulb.
- Stage lighting and light show devices can cause not lighting, blinking, and drastically shortened lamp
life.
- Not a concentrated light source.
- The light curve is not flat. It is usually somewhat flat, but with gaps and bright-line spikes in
it.
- Can not provide a flat continuous spectrum for scientific purposes.
- See below for scientific, color identification, matching, and artistry solutions.
- Provides many different colors and tints for interior decorating purposes.
- Will not work for electronic devices that use incandescent filaments as ballasting loads.
- Useless as a heat source.
- Contains mercury, which scares Democrats to death.
- Color temperature is determined by the phosphor mix.
- Where multiple turns of tubing are placed closely together (as in the squiggle bulbs), light from one
tube is lost by striking another tube instead of radiating into the room.
- Three-way bulb switches in multiple lamp fixtures shorten CFL life by a factor of two.
- Often the power supply fails earlier than the light element itself.
|
COMPACT FLUORESCENT LAMPS (CFL) - BRIGHT LINE
Spectrum: |
|
The problems:
- Will not physically fit some fixtures. Often the screw shell is recessed too far. Try an outlet tap
screw shell adapter.
- Most burn out faster if inside enclosed indoor fixtures.
- Can't be used in hostile environments.
- Outdoor uses might work if the fixture is enclosed.
- Touch lamps might work if one incandescent lamp load is still connected.
- Motion detector security fixtures drastically shorten the lives of these.
- Dimmers require a dimmable bulb.
- Stage lighting and light show devices cause not lighting, blinking, and drastically shortening lamp
life.
- Not a concentrated light source.
- The light curve is not flat. It has an 8 or 9 line bright-line spectrum with no fill between the
lines.
- Can not provide a flat continuous spectrum for scientific purposes.
- See below for scientific, color identification, matching, and artistry solutions.
- Provides many different colors and tints for interior decorating purposes.
- Will not work for electronic devices that use incandescent filaments as ballasting loads.
- Useless as a heat source.
- Contains mercury, but not as much as the other fluorescent designs.
- Color temperature is determined by the mix of gases.
- Where multiple turns of tubing are placed closely together (as in the squiggle bulbs), light from one
tube is lost by striking another tube instead of radiating into the room.
- Three-way bulb switches on multiple lamp fixtures shorten CFL life by a factor of two.
- Often the power supply fails earlier than the light element itself.
|
LIGHT EMITTING DIODE (LED) - RGB
Spectrum: |
|
The problems:
- Will not physically fit some fixtures. Often the screw shell is recessed too far. Try an outlet tap
screw shell adapter.
- Can often handle cold environments, but heat would cause it to fail quickly. Often has a heat radiating
surface.
- Outdoor uses are usually prohibited in the instructions. Check the box.
- Touch lamps might work if one incandescent lamp load is still connected.
- The nonsinusoidal waveform has caused the relays of timers and motion detectors to weld in the on
position, even at the reduced currents.
- The LED lamps with switching power supplies cause more compatibility troubles than the ones with simple
rectifier/filter circuits.
- Motion detector security fixtures might work if one incandescent lamp load is still connected.
- Dimmers work quite well with rectifier/filter types if one incandescent load is still connected.
Switching supply types do not work.
- Dimmable bulbs are available.
- Stage lighting and light show devices work quite well with rectifier/filter types if one incandescent
load is still connected.
- Some new stage lighting and light show devices are designed to use only LEDs.
- Can meet low power needs for a concentrated light source for focused lighting or projection
equipment.
- The light curve is not flat. It has three bands of nearly single color light (red, green, and blue),
with gaps in between.
- Can not provide a flat continuous spectrum for scientific purposes.
- Can not be used for colorimetry.
- See below for scientific, color identification, matching, and artistry solutions.
- An increasing palette of colors and tints are available for interior decorating purposes. Some can be
set for different colors.
- Not useful for ballasting loads.
- Useless as a heat source.
- Color temperature is determined by the relative currents through the three LEDs.
- Usually the power supply fails earlier than the light element itself.
|
LIGHT EMITTING DIODE (LED) - PHOSPHOR
Spectrum: |
|
The problems:
- Will not physically fit some fixtures. Often the screw shell is recessed too far. Try an outlet tap
screw shell adapter.
- Can handle cold environments, but heat would cause it to fail quickly.
- Outdoor uses are usually prohibited in the instructions. Check the box.
- With some brands, a sudden power sag causes the LED bulb to turn off. The switch must be turned off,
then on, to light it again.
- Touch lamps might work if one incandescent lamp load is still connected.
- The nonsinusoidal waveform has caused the relays of timers and motion detectors to weld in the on
position, even at reduced currents.
- The LED lamps with switching power supplies cause more compatibility troubles than the ones with simple
rectifier/filter circuits.
- Motion detector security fixtures might work if one incandescent lamp load is still connected.
- Dimmers work quite well with rectifier/filter types if one incandescent load is still connected.
Switching supply types do not work.
- Dimmable bulbs are available.
- Stage lighting and light show devices work quite well with rectifier/filter types if one incandescent
load is still connected.
- Some new stage lighting and light show devices are designed to use only use LED lamps.
- Can meet low power needs for a concentrated light source for focused lighting or projection
equipment.
- The light curve is not flat. It has two bands: One band has blue light. The other covers red, yellow,
and green. There is a gap between the bands. The lamp emits no deep red, cyan, or violet.
- Can not provide a flat continuous spectrum for scientific purposes.
- Can not be used for colorimetry.
- See below for scientific, color identification, matching, and artistry solutions.
- An increasing palette of colors and tints are available for interior decorating purposes. Some lamps
can be set to make different colors.
- Not useful for ballasting loads.
- Useless as a heat source.
- Color temperature is determined by the amount and type of phosphor.
- Usually the power supply fails earlier than the light element itself.
|
MERCURY VAPOR
Spectra: |
|
|
The problems:
- The bulbs are too large and too powerful for home use. 400 W was a typical size.
- The high voltages needed are not allowed by electrical codes for indoor home use in some areas.
- These don't fit standard screw shells. A ballast is required.
- Some environments would cause quick failure.
- Outdoor use is an expected normal use.
- Long warm up/restrike time of several minutes precludes use in touch lamps, motion detectors, and light
show equipment.
- Dimmers won't work.
- Useless for stage lighting.
- Can possibly meet the need for a concentrated light source.
- The light curve is not flat. It has 4 or 5 bright lines. Some also have a low level continuous or band
spectrum from a phosphor on the glass.
- Can not provide a flat continuous spectrum for scientific purposes.
- Can not be used for colorimetry.
- Useless for scientific, color identification, matching, and artistry solutions.
- Harsh light is useless for interior decorating.
- Not useful as a ballasting load.
- Not useful as a heat source.
- Source of ultraviolet light unless shielded.
- Contains mercury, which scares Democrats to death.
- Color temperature is high.
|
LOW PRESSURE SODIUM (LPS)
The problems:
- The bulbs are too large and too powerful for home use. 400 W is a typical size.
- The high voltages and temperatures needed are not allowed by electrical codes for indoor home use in
some areas.
- These don't fit or work in standard screw shells.
- Some environments would cause quick failure.
- Outdoor use is an expected normal use.
- Long warm up/restrike time of several minutes precludes use in touch lamps, motion detectors, and light
show equipment.
- Dimmers won't work.
- Useless for stage lighting.
- Can possibly meet the need for a concentrated light source.
- The light curve is not flat. It has two closely spaced bright lines. The light is essentially
monochromatic yellow.
- Can not provide a flat continuous spectrum for scientific purposes.
- Can not be used for colorimetry.
- Useless for scientific, color identification, matching, and artistry solutions.
- Harsh light is useless for interior decorating.
- Not useful as a ballasting load.
- Not useful as a heat source.
- Color temperature is not defined, as only two lines of yellow light are produced.
|
HIGH PRESSURE SODIUM (HPS)
Spectrum: |
|
The problems:
- The bulbs are too large and too powerful for home use. 400 W is a typical size.
- The high voltages and temperatures needed are not allowed by electrical codes for indoor home use in
some areas.
- These don't fit or work in standard screw shells.
- Some environments would cause quick failure.
- Outdoor use is an expected normal use.
- Long warm up/restrike time of several minutes precludes use in touch lamps, motion detectors, and light
show equipment.
- Dimmers won't work.
- Useless for stage lighting.
- Can possibly meet the need for a concentrated light source.
- The light curve is not flat. It has a nearly continuous spectrum in the reds and yellows, but 7 bright
lines for other colors.
- Can not provide a flat continuous spectrum for scientific purposes.
- Can not be used for colorimetry.
- See below for scientific, color identification, matching, and artistry solutions.
- Harsh light is useless for interior decorating.
- Not useful as a ballasting load.
- Not useful as a heat source.
- Contains mercury, which scares Democrats to death.
- Color temperature is very low.
|
HIGH INTENSITY DISCHARGE (HID)
Spectrum: |
|
The problems:
- Until recently, the bulbs were too large and too powerful for home use. 400 W was a typical size.
Automotive uses have reduced size.
- The high voltages and temperatures needed for large sizes are not allowed by electrical codes for indoor
home use in some areas.
- These don't fit standard screw shells, and need special circuitry.
- Some environments would cause quick failure.
- Outdoor use is an expected normal use.
- Long warm up/restrike time of several minutes precludes use of large sizes in touch lamps, motion
detectors, and light show equipment.
- With a proper rectifier/filter power supply and special ballasting, small sizes might be used in touch
lamps, motion detectors, and light show equipment.
- Dimmers won't work.
- Useless for stage lighting.
- Can possibly meet the need for a concentrated light source.
- The light curve is not flat. It has a nearly continuous spectrum with 9 to 12 bright lines superimposed
(varies with manufacturer choice).
- Can not provide a flat continuous spectrum for scientific purposes.
- Can not be used for colorimetry.
- See below for scientific, color identification, matching, and artistry solutions.
- Harsh light is often inappropriate for interior decorating, but it can be filtered.
- Not useful as a ballasting load.
- Not useful as a heat source.
- Color temperature is determined by the mix of gases and metallic salts.
|
INDUCTION PLASMA SULFUR
The problems:
- Requires a new kind of fixture.
- Quite expensive (Typical fixture is $1000).
- The bulbs are too large and too powerful for home use. 1000 W was a typical size. Now, 250 W is the
smallest size.
- The fixture is large. The ballast is almost 2 cubic feet.
- The high voltages and temperatures needed are not allowed by electrical codes for indoor home use in
some areas.
- Some environments would cause quick failure.
- Some versions require spinning the bulb to cool it. Needs monitoring for maintenance purposes.
- Will not work in an enclosed fixture space. Must have ventilation.
- Outdoor use is an expected normal use.
- Long warm up/restrike time of 5 minutes precludes use in touch lamps, motion detectors, and light
show equipment.
- Standard dimmers won't work.
- Useless for stage lighting.
- Not useful for a concentrated light source.
- Useful for photometry and colorimetry equipment
- Provides a flat continuous spectrum for scientific purposes.
- Meets the need for accurate visual color identification.
- Meets the need to visually match colors made through different processes accurately
- Meets the artist's need for balanced light to create in.
- If the size can be reduced, meets the artistic need for balanced light for interior decorating
purposes
- Might provide many different colors and tints for interior decorating purposes in the future.
- Not useful as a ballasting load.
- Not useful as a heat source.
- Color temperature is determined by the temperature of the plasma.
- Usually the power supply fails earlier than the light element itself.
|
INDUCTION PLASMA MERCURY
The problems:
- Requires a new kind of fixture.
- Quite expensive (Typical fixture is $1000).
- The bulbs are too large and too powerful for home use. 1000 W was a typical size. Now, 250 W is the
smallest size.
- The fixture is large. The ballast is almost 2 cubic feet.
- The high voltages and temperatures needed are not allowed by electrical codes for indoor home use in
some areas.
- Some environments would cause quick failure.
- Will not work in an enclosed fixture space. Must have ventilation.
- Outdoor use is an expected normal use.
- Long warm up/restrike time of 5 minutes precludes use in touch lamps, motion detectors, and light
show equipment.
- Standard dimmers won't work.
- Useless for stage lighting.
- Not useful for a concentrated light source.
- Provides a flat continuous spectrum for scientific purposes.
- Meets the need for accurate visual color identification.
- Meets the need to visually match colors made through different processes accurately
- Meets the artist's need for balanced light to create in.
- If the size can be reduced, meets the artistic need for balanced light for interior decorating
purposes
- Might provide many different colors and tints for interior decorating purposes in the future.
- Not useful as a ballasting load.
- Not useful as a heat source.
- Color temperature is determined by the mix of gases.
- Contains mercury, but not as much as the other fluorescent designs.
- Usually the power supply fails earlier than the light element itself.
|
ELECTRON STIMULATED LUMINESCENCE (ESL)
The problems:
- Will not physically fit some fixtures. Often the screw shell is recessed too far. Try an outlet tap
screw shell adapter.
- Hard to find.
- Some environments would cause quick failure.
- Outdoor use unknown at this time
- Warm up/restrike time is a few seconds
- Standard dimmers may not work
- Not useful for stage lighting.
- Not a concentrated light source
- Might be useful for photometry and colorimetry equipment with the correct phosphor mix
- The light curve is adjustable by changing the phosphor mix
- Has the advantage of the phosphors from the old style fluorescent lamps without the superimposed
mercury spectrum lines.
- Spectrum for scientific purposes can be adjusted by changing the phosphor mix
- Scientific, color identification, matching, and artistry depend on the phosphor mix.
- Might provide many different colors and tints for interior decorating purposes in the future.
- Not useful as a ballasting load.
- Not useful as a heat source.
- Color temperature is determined by the phosphor mix.
- Often the power supply fails earlier than the light element itself.
|
XENON FLASHTUBE
The problems:
- Not useful as a lighting source, but included for photographic flash, strobe light, and comparison
purposes
- Some environments would cause quick failure.
- Outdoor use OK in enclosure
- Warm up is instant. Restrike time depends on power supply. Will not sustain light longer than a few
milliseconds.
- Standard dimmers do not work
- Not useful for normal stage lighting, used for lightning effects.
- Can be a concentrated light source
- Not useful for photometry and colorimetry equipment
- The bright line spectrum is useless for scientific purposes involving color
- Useless for scientific, color identification, matching, and artistry purposes
- Useless for interior decorating purposes
- Not useful as a ballasting load.
- Not useful as a heat source.
- Color temperature is determined by the gas pressure and voltage.
|
NEON TUBES
The problems:
- Not useful as a lighting source by itself, but included for comparison purposes
- A few environments would cause failure.
- Outdoor use OK in enclosure
- Warm up and restrike are instant.
- Standard dimmers do not work
- Not useful for normal stage lighting
- Can be a concentrated light source
- Not useful for photometry and colorimetry equipment
- The bright line spectrum of neon is useless for scientific purposes involving color
- The white color is essentially a fluorescent lamp.
- The blue color is essentially a mercury vapor lamp.
- The yellow color is essentially a fluorescent lamp with a yellow phosphor.
- The green color is essentially a fluorescent lamp with a green phosphor.
- Useless for scientific, color identification, matching, and artistry purposes
- Useful for exotic interior decorating purposes
- Not useful as a ballasting load.
- Not useful as a heat source.
- Color temperature is determined by the gas mix and the phosphor mix.
|
DEALING WITH LIGHT CURVES THAT ARE NOT FLAT
The problems related to light curves that are not linear (or Planckian) and flat can be dealt with in
several ways. But the method used depends on the task at hand and the type of lamp. Trading flatness of the
spectral curve for lamp efficiency is an unacceptable trade off, but that is what is being done.
The following are the tasks that normally need a flat light spectrum:
- Scientific measurements
- Emission Spectrophotometry
- Reflection Spectrophotometry
- Transmission Spectrophotometry
- Colorimetry
- Accurate visual color identification
- Accurate visual color matching
- Mixing color pigments for product use
- Mixing color pigments for art
- Colored light for interior decorating
- Photography
Each use will be dealt with separately:
Scientific measurements
Various scientific measurements are taken using light, including how much light an object reflects, and
the spectrum of the light emitted or reflected by an object. The flatness of the light used affects the
measurements. Usually one of the measurements below has the characteristics needed for any other scientific
measurement.
One effect that can spoil the readings is fluorescence. Many pigments and base materials fluoresce under
ultraviolet light, including cotton, many kinds of paper, and a large number of yellow pigments. These
fluorescent effects can change the readings if ultraviolet light from the source is also shining on the
sample. Since the object may be used under the source providing ultraviolet light, the tests should be made
with and without a UV blocking filter covering the light source. Blue light can also cause some
fluorescence.
Emission Spectrophotometry
In emission photometry, the amount of light emitted by the test source is measured at each wavelength.
Since no other light source is used for the measurement, the primary problem is finding an accurate flat or
Planckian source for calibrating the equipment.
If the light source is not in the laboratory (e.g. photometry used in astronomy), the problem is light
pollution. Light from sources in the area reflect off the atmosphere and into the measuring equipment,
including the bright lines from sodium, mercury, CFLs, and HID lamps. One possible way to compensate is to
take a reading of the background light reflected off the atmosphere at the same time, and use a computer to
subtract it from the reading.
Reflection Spectrophotometry
Here, the light source is reflected off the sample and into the measuring equipment. The chief way to
compensate for the non-flat nature of the source is to compare the reading to a reading taken from the source
itself at the same wavelength at the same time. This is done with two identical detectors, one receiving
dispersed light from the sample, and the other receiving dispersed light directly from the light source.
In this case, the only requirement is that the source must emit light at all wavelengths under test. This
excludes all of the bright-line sources, leaving the incandescent, halogen, phosphor fluorescent, phosphor
HID, sulfur lamps, and ESL.
Transmission Spectrophotometry
Here, the light source is passed through the sample and into the measuring equipment. The methods for
reflection spectrophotometry work here too. Again, the only requirement is that the source must emit light
at all wavelengths under test.
Colorimetry
While not as stringent as spectrophotometry, colorimetry is an attempt to measure the RGB color content of
reflected light in the same way the human eye receives it. Special red, green, and blue color filters are
used, and the reading is compared to the reading of the unfiltered light source. When used with a flat or
Planckian light source, colorimetry returns the same values for most color temperatures of light. It is a
measure of the percentage of light absorbed.
One problem with colorimetry is that the result depends on the light source. A flat or Planckian light
source is assumed. The results are very different when bright lines or spectral gaps are introduced into the
light source. One solution is to use several different light sources, and report readings taken from each
source.
Accurate visual color identification
Accurate color identification is needed where color codes are used to identify different electronic
components, wires in a cable, sizes of tools, or any other place where a color marking on an object is used
to identify it. An example is the resistor color code used in electronics. Bands of color are used to
indicate the resistance and tolerance of the part.
Part of the problem is that different manufacturers use different color pigments to indicate the same
color. If the light source contains bright lines, or does not have a continuous spectrum, the pigments used
by different manufacturers might produce wrong or ambiguous responses.
One solution is to have a guide with different samples of colors and the names of the colors they are
supposed to be. Another solution is to provide a flat or Planckian light source for the task. With this
solution, avoid the warm colors preferred for office use. A third solution is to use multiple light sources
of different types.
Accurate visual color matching
Here the problem is finding a color that matches a desired color. The light is critical for this use.
The best solution is to use several light sources, and repeat the matching test under each one. If the colors
fail to match under any one source, the colors do not match.
Rather than waiting for some of the sources to start and come up to optimum light, it is better to move
the color samples and standards from one place to another. A series of small booths next to each other, each
with a different light source, is an ideal way to do this. Another way for larger objects is to put shutters
on each light source, blocking it when it is not needed.
Mixing color pigments for product use
The problem here is to make sure the components of a product, made in factories many miles apart, match
when the product is assembled. A product that has colors that match under some lights, but not under other
lights, might seem to be cheaply made. Clothing is one such case. Another example is an automobile, with
plastic and metal parts that are supposed to be the same color.
The method used for color matching used above should be used, but additionally, sunlight, northern sky
daylight, and an overcast sky should be used, to make sure the product looks right in all conditions. One
method to make matching easier is to use the primary pigments magenta, yellow, and cyan to make the pigment
mix. Mixes made using these pigments match under many sources of light without adjustment.
Another related case is that of uniforms (or other sets of products that must all be the same color).
When several different manufacturers, often at separated times, make uniforms for the same use, they must
all use the above color matching technique, plus colorimetry, to make sure the uniforms match under all
light sources. The test should be made under all known sources of artificial light, and also include
sunlight, northern sky daylight, an overcast sky, and candles. The light sources used for match tests should
be part of the specifications made for the order.
Mixing color pigments for art
Here, the problem is not matching a specific color, but keeping the color from changing into another color
under a different kind of light. Two techniques are useful here:
- View the work and the mixing palette under more than one kind of light: An arrangement to switch sources
of light, or a series of booths with different kinds of light, works well. Usually the following sources
will be sufficient: Halogen, 2700K CFL, 6500K CFL, both CFLs on together, LED Phosphor, and HID. But Mercury
vapor, sodium vapor, and sulfur are not necessary unless the work is part of a traveling show where the
existing light source at the venue must be used. Where the source can not be rapidly lit and extinguished,
use a shutter box to contain it, or use booths.
- Use mixtures of the pigment primaries Cyan, Magenta, and Yellow. These retain their intended colors
under more light sources than any other mixtures (as shown in the
Crayon Trials. This is because each pigment acts in only one region of
the spectrum. Cyan removes red light, magenta removes green light, and yellow removes blue light. The visual
ratios sent to the eye usually match the Planckian ratios expected to come from the source of light
present.
- Avoid using colors that change hue with concentration, due to light curve slope effects. They are most
susceptible to different light sources. The usual RYB primaries cause this effect.
The artist must also check to see if any of his pigments fluoresce. Use an ultraviolet source and a blue
source to check this.
Colored light for interior decorating
This is not so much a matter of selection of the original light source, but of matching the effect with
another light source, because the original source is no longer available. Usually matching the color
temperature suffices, but the use of sources containing bright-line spectra may visually cause the colors of
objects and surfaces in the room to change. Experimentation with multiple sources of different types is
advisable here. A check for fluorescence is advisable too, to prevent color surprises.
Choosing colors for interior decorating
Look at the color samples under the types of light that will be used in the actual space. It might be
advisable to take actual samples of the colors to be used into the actual space.
Never use a swatchbook printed on a color printer or mass-produced using three-color (CMY) or four-color
(CMYK) printing to match pigment colors or select paint colors for a room. Anything other than a swatch of
the actual paint or pigment used is useless for this purpose. The actual pigment will be affected by
different lights in ways different from the way the inks in the swatchbook will be affected.
Photography
There are several issues to deal with when color photography is attempted in various kinds of lighting.
This is complicated by the difference between film photography and digital photography. In addition, the
flash on the camera is often either xenon or magnesium, producing yet another light source. The issues are as
follows:
- Color temperature: For both film and digital photography, the colors can be adjusted in the lab (or on
the computer) to cancel out this effect. Adjusting the ratio of red and blue in the picture is usually
sufficient, and is done automatically by film developing machines.
- Green/Violet ratio: This is usually not a problem, but can be induced by the bright lines in
fluorescent, CFL, LED, and HID sources. This is also lab/computer adjustable, and is often done
automatically.
- Adjustments for color temperature and Green/Violet ratio to correct whites can cause other colors to be
wrong.
- Flesh tones: these are usually taken care of by the two adjustments above. Occasionally, a bright line
in the light source changes flesh tones in relation to the background colors. Or the flash on the camera
provides a different color balance than the light in the background. Often the background is sacrificed in
favor of the flesh tones.
- The effects of bright lines on individual colors: Occasionally, a bright line in the spectrum of the
available light causes the color of a particular object being photographed to shift away from the intended
color. Thus, a yellow object may look orange, brown, or green in the photo. Changing to a different light
source helps. After the picture is taken, the cure is often dodging during color printing, or applying color
correction to only a portion of the digital image.
- Fluorescence of the object under the ultraviolet light from the flash, or from a room light, may change
the color produced by photography.
- Magnesium flash is an incandescent source. Xenon is a bright line source, but has a very large number of
bright lines.
- Sometimes the dyes used in photographic prints or slides appear to change color when viewed using
different light sources.
Build a full-spectrum source
Fortunately, we can combine sources to produce a light source containing all wavelengths of visible light
in roughly equal amounts. Usually one or two LED sources are combined with sources that provide the missing
wavelengths.
This page on a Full Spectrum Light Source shows one way to do this.
The main restriction on this method is that no bright-line sources can be used.
|
DEALING WITH RELAYS, SILICON CONTROLLED RECTIFIERS, AND TRIACS
The problems:
- An inductive load, such as an inductive ballast, can keep a triac or silicon controlled rectifier (SCR)
from turning off. This locks the light on, or makes it flash on and off. Use a capacitor in parallel with
the lamp to remove the phase shift. It also causes an inductive kick when power is shut off, causing damage
to relay contacts.
- A rectifier/filter power supply usually draws power only at the highest peaks of the powerline cycle.
This causes harmonics of the powerline frequency to get onto the power line, and fools SCR and triac
switching devices. It can also cause relay contacts to pit or weld, causing loss of control. Reducing the
size of the filter capacitor, and doing more filtering farther down the line can help here.
- A switching power supply uses a rectifier/filter supply with low filtering to power a high frequency
(20-100 KHz) oscillator. The oscillator then feeds a high-frequency transformer, and a rectifier/filter
with a much smaller filter capacitor. This is unpredictable when used with SCRs and triacs. It can also
cause relay contacts to pit or weld by raising voltages above normal levels, causing loss of control.
- Arc lamps, including neon, fluorescent, and metallic vapor lamps, draw current only when the voltage is
at a peak level in the powerline cycle. This causes harmonics to get back into the power lines, and plays
havoc with SCR, triac, and relay controls.
- To protect relays in AC circuits, bypass them with capacitors large enough to prevent contact arcs, but
small enough to not cause the device to operate. Be sure to check the device in the actual circuit, to make
sure the capacitor does not cause spurious or improper operation when the relay is off. Also make sure the
device shuts down correctly.
- To protect relays in DC circuits, connect a rectifier diode across the contacts, with the diode reverse
biased. Any inductive kick will pass through the diode instead of damaging the contacts.
- Nonlinear current draw can be somewhat compensated for with a resonant transformer/capacitor network.
This will always keep the current moving at the power line frequency, storing up energy, and then delivering
it at the high points, without suddenly drawing extra current from the lines at the high points. This helps
SCRs, triacs, and relays work.
- Special dimmers have been made that are less affected by load type. They are three-terminal devices
that also need the neutral to use as a reference for the timing of phase-control dimmers.
- A special network can be inserted between the dimmer and the bulb to adjust the waveform that each
device gets.
|
DEALING WITH POWER FACTOR, HARMONICS, and NOISE
Power factor is the portion of the power on the power lines that actually came from the generator.
Resistive loads give the best (highest) power factor of 1. A purely reactive load (a capacitor or coil) gives
a 90 degree leading or lagging phase shift between voltage and current, and a power factor of 0. A low power
factor causes more current to flow through the power lines than that coming from the generators. This means
the power company must put in larger power lines.
Harmonics are multiples of the powerline frequency that are fed back into the power lines by nonlinear
loads, such as gas discharge tubes, rectifiers, and light emitting diodes. They also cause more power to
flow through the lines than the generators produce. They also cause mistiming in phase controlled SCR or
triac circuits, and can cause overvoltage problems that can damage semiconductors, and relay and switch
contacts.
The problems:
- Electric motors are inductive in nature. They cause current to lag behind the voltage, lowering the
power factor. Capacitors cause current to lead the voltage, so they can be connected across motors to
correct the power factor.
- It is better to connect the capacitor to the motor, so it is connected only when the motor is running.
But too many power users will not pay for the capacitors for small motors, so the power company has to
provide them on the power poles.
- Nonlinear devices, such as gas discharge arc lights, rectifier/filter power supplies, switching power
supplies, and light emitting semiconductors, cause simultaneous leading and lagging currents, because the
currents flow for only a short portion of the powerline cycle. There is no easy way to completely
compensate for this. But some devices can partially compensate for it:
- A properly tuned transformer and capacitor combination can feed any kind of load, while looking like
a nearly resistive load to the power source feeding it.
- Extra rectifiers connected to phase-shift networks can smooth out the loading of a rectifier/filter
power supply.
- Similar devices could also smooth out the draw of a switching power supply.
- Nonlinear devices, such as gas discharge arc lights, rectifier/filter power supplies, switching power
supplies, and light emitting semiconductors, cause harmonics to be fed back into the power lines. This
increases the current in power lines like low power factor does, and can also cause malfunctions in
electronic clocks and carrier current devices (power line remote control). The following devices can
compensate for this:
- A properly tuned transformer and capacitor combination can feed any kind of load, while looking like
a nearly resistive load to the power source feeding it.
- A choke input and output filter can remove the harmonics without interfering with carrier
currents.
- Shifting the phase of some of the lamps can smooth out the load somewhat, but cannot completely
remove the harmonics.
- Switching power supplies and gas discharge devices put noise on the power lines, causing radio and TV
interference, and malfunctions in electronic clocks, computers, and carrier current devices. The following
devices can compensate for this:
- A properly tuned transformer and capacitor combination can feed any kind of load, while looking like
a nearly resistive load to the power source feeding it.
- A choke input and output filter can remove the noise without interfering with carrier currents.
|
DEALING WITH SHORT LAMP LIFE
Certain lamps are not designed for certain uses. Misusing them greatly shortens the life of the lamp.
Other lamps are not designed to produce the lamp life promised on the package because of factors other than
the life of the light-emitting element. Here are some of the factors causing shorter than expected lamp
life:
- The lamp is turned on and off too frequently - The average fluorescent lamp or CFL is usually good for
about 6500 starts. The act of turning the lamp on is what wears it out, not leaving it on. So fluorescent
lamps and CFLs should not be used in applications where they are switched on and off frequently or flashed.
Do not use them for security lights with motion detectors. They should also be avoided for light show
displays. Note that, because the lifetime is determined by number of starts, not the time the lamp is left
on, the life in hours posted on the box are nonsense, but the law requires it to be there.
- Many types of lamps have shorter lives when the lamp is dimmed. This includes most gas discharge lamps
and all lamps with switching power supplies that are not designed to be dimmed.
- A line voltage other than the rated value can shorten the lives of many kinds of lamps. A voltage that
is too high will ruin most kinds of lamps. A voltage that is too low will cause electrode failure in some
kinds, and cause others to fail to light even though nothing is wrong with them.
- Many lamps fail because the power supplies in the lamp bases overheat. This usually happens because the
lamp base does not get enough ventilation to keep it cool. Some cheap brands skimp on heat dissipation. Be
sure a lamp is rated for enclosed use before putting it in an enclosed fixture.
- Often the lifetime of the light emitting element is the life posted on the box, even though some of the
components in the power supply in the base have shorter lives.
- Some components in the power supply in the lamp base (particularly electrolytic capacitors) have shelf
lives that start timing when the part was made, not when the lamp was installed. A lamp of this type can
lose all of its life sitting on the shelf as a replacement bulb.
- Electrical surges from thunderstorms can damage the components of the power supply in the base of the
lamp, causing early failure. Surges can also damage some of the individual LEDs in the LED bulb, causing a
reduction in the light output.
- Sunlight falling on a white LED can cause the phosphor to degrade, making the lamp dimmer and bluer
than it was when new.
|
DEALING WITH OTHER PROBLEMS
Solutions to other problems:
New lamps too big to fit
Use different bulb or replace fixture.
Need different power supply or fixture type
Use different bulb or replace fixture.
Can't use existing dimmers
Use different kind of bulb or replace dimmer.
Can't get T12 fluorescent bulb
Either the fixture or the ballast must be replaced.
Changes in how things look
Use a different kind of bulb.
Filters give wrong colors
Use a different kind of bulb or a different color filter.
New lamps deny outdoor use
Use a different kind of bulb.
Motion detectors wear out CFLs
Use a different kind of bulb.
Can't use light show controller
Use a different kind of bulb.
Motion image shade won't rotate
Use a halogen bulb.
Lamps can't be flashed rapidly
Use a different kind of bulb.
|
3-Way bulb switch wears out CFLs
Use a different kind of bulb.
UV light turns plastic yellow
Use a different kind of bulb.
Heat melts plastic lampshade
Use a different kind of bulb.
Rainbow lampshade has no color
Use a different kind of bulb.
Light makes reading difficult
Use a different kind of bulb.
Can't use enclosed fixture
Use a different kind of bulb.
Floodlight husk overheats bulb
Use a different kind of bulb.
Bulb sticks out of tulip shade
Use a different kind of bulb.
Bulb-clip shade won't work
Use a different kind of bulb.
Bare squiggle bulb looks awful
Use a different kind of bulb.
Stroboscope disc gives no reading
Use bulb flashing at AC power rate.
|
|
DESIGNING COMPATIBLE ELECTRONICS
Dear Manufacturers: Points to consider when designing more efficient lamps:
- A flat continuous spectrum is much better than a bright line spectrum or a spectrum of multiple
nonoverlapping bands. It has a CRI of 100.
- Give users either a wide choice of color temperatures, or an adjustable color temperature control.
- Also provide a variety of colors, including the primary colors of light.
- Use the standard names for the color temperatures of the lamps:
- 2700 K Soft White (orange)
- 3000 K Warm White (orangish)
- 3500 K Bright White (yellow-orangish)
- 4100 K Cool White (yellowish)
- 5500 K Worklight (green tinge)
- 6000 K SunLight (close to white)
- 6500 K Daylight (blue tinge)
- 7500 K Skylight (bluish)
- 9500 K Plant Light (blue-white)
Don't make up your own names. It confuses consumers.
- The best design is one that looks like a resistive load to the power source. It causes the fewest
compatibility problems.
- A properly tuned transformer and capacitor combination can feed any kind of load, while looking like a
nearly resistive load to the power source feeding it.
- Avoid switching power supplies. They cause more problems than anything else.
- Simple rectifier circuits and LEDs in series work well. With a small (7W) resistive load in parallel,
these light well and can be dimmed.
- Extra rectifiers connected to phase-shift networks can smooth out the loading of a rectifier/filter
power supply. Similar devices could also smooth out the draw of a switching power supply. But they do not
remove switching frequencies.
- A resonant transformer and capacitor combination can feed any kind of load, while looking like a nearly
resistive load to the power source feeding it.
- A choke input and output filter can remove the harmonics without interfering with carrier control
systems.
- Remember that customers might have unusual uses with existing equipment, such as stage lighting, light
shows, heat lamps, advertising displays, chase lights, various kinds of dimmers, 60 Hz stroboscope discs,
light bulbs used as variable resistance loads, and other special devices. Don't render their equipment
useless.
|
THE STUPID BULB
A manufacturer has made a yellow bug bulb that does not work. It still attracts bugs.
The details:
- A light bulb attracts bugs because they mistake it for the sun or the moon.
- Insects navigate by keeping the sun or the moon at a constant angle in their compound eyes.
- The sun and the moon are so far away that the angle of the light never changes.
- A light source fools the bugs. It is close enough that the angle changes. The bug compensates by
changing its direction of flight to keep the angle constant. Thus, the bug keeps circling the light
instead of following its original straight path.
- Most insects see a band of light from green into the ultraviolet.
- A bug light works by not emitting light that bugs can see. Thus, it emits only yellow, orange, and
red light.
- Humans can see what they are doing with only yellow, orange, and red light.
- A sharp cutoff filter keeps the incandescent bug light from emitting any cyan, blue, violet,
or ultraviolet light, and very little green. Thus, the bugs don't mistake this light for the moon.
- This stupid bug lamp makes the color yellow by mixing red and green light from phosphors. It looks
yellow to the customer, but emits a lot of green light. The yellow seen in this panel on your monitor
is made the same way.
- Bugs can see this green light as bright. Thus, they are attracted to this lamp.
The stupid bulb is made by Feit, which is otherwise a manufacturer of fine products.
|
- Ballast - An electronic device that limits current to the lamp
- Band Spectrum - Emission of light in a band of wavelengths
- Black Body Radiation - Light emitted by a perfectly black object heated to
incandescence
- Bright-Line Spectrum - Light emitted by a hot gas, consisting of a number of discrete
wavelengths, with no other light emitted
- CFL - Compact Fluorescent Lamp
- Color Rendering Index (CRI) - The quality of a lamp, measured by correctness of
identification and matching of colors
- Color Temperature - The point on the Planckian locus of temperature of incandescence,
tinting white light with color
- Compact Fluorescent Lamp - A small fluorescent lamp that fits a standard Edison base
socket.
- Complex Power - The vector sum of resistive power and reactive power, measured in
volt-amperes
- Concentrated Light Source - A light source small enough that it can be used for
projectors and spotlights
- Continuous Spectrum - Light emitted at all visible wavelengths, with a flat or gently
sloped output curve
- Electron Stimulated Luminescence (ESL) - Light produced by electrons beamed art a
phosphor, as done in an older TV set
- Fluorescence - Light of one color (including ultraviolet) causing a phosphor to emit
light of a different color
- Fluorescent Lamp - An electric arc lamp containing mercury that emits ultraviolet
light, which then excites phosphors
- Halogen - One of the elements fluorine, chlorine, bromine, or iodine
- Halogen Lamp - An incandescent lamp filled with halogen gases, which keep the filament
from eroding
- Harmonics - Multiples of a fundamental frequency (such as the 60Hz powerline
frequency), causing the waveform to change.
- HID - High Intensity Discharge
- High Intensity Discharge - An electric arc lamp filled with chosen metallic salts,
producing a bright-line spectrum
- High Pressure Sodium Vapor Lamp - An electric arc lamp filled with high pressure sodium
salt, so it emits many bright lines
- Idiot - Any public official who thinks that banning products is the solution to
anything.
- Incandescence - Heating a material hot enough that it emits light in a Planckian
continuous spectrum
- Incandescent Lamp - A lamp with a carbon or tungsten filament that incandesces when
electricity is passed through it
- Induction Plasma Lamp - A tube filled with a material that incandesces when current is
induced in it by a coil of wire
- LED - Light Emitting Diode
- Light Emitting Diode - A semiconductor that is doped to give off a band spectrum of
light when electrified
- Low Pressure Sodium Vapor Lamp - An electric arc lamp filled with low pressure sodium
salt, emitting only two yellow lines
- Mercury Plasma Lamp - An inductive plasma lamp with mercury as the active
ingredient
- Mercury Vapor Lamp - an electric arc lamp containing mercury, emitting only 4 visible
bright lines, plus ultraviolet
- Metallic Arc Lamp - HID lamp
- Phosphor - A substance that absorbs energy from one wavelength of light, producing a
band spectrum of other wavelengths
- Photon - An individual packet of light energy. Each photon has its own wavelength and
direction of travel.
- Planckian Curve - The hump-shaped emission intensity curve produced by
incandescence
- Planckian Locus - The curve representing the colors of light given off by incandescence
at different temperatures
- Plasma - A state of matter where the atoms are hot, ionized, and emitting light
- Power - The amount of energy per second used by a device, calculated by multiplying
voltage by current to obtain watts
- Power Factor - Cosine of power phase angle, with values of 1 for purely resistive
loads, and 0 for purely reactive loads
- Power Phase Angle - The angle between the voltage peak and the current peak of complex
power
- Reactive Power - Power with the current leading or lagging the voltage by 90 degrees,
caused by coils or capacitors
- Rectifier/Filter Power Supply - Produces wanted voltage using transformers, rectifiers,
and large capacitors
- Resistive Power - Power with the voltage and current in phase, as found with a purely
resistive load
- Sinusoidal Waveform - The smooth waveform of alternating current. Causes no power
problems. The waveform of a photon
- Spectral Gap - A portion of the visible spectrum with no light from the lamp
- Spectrum - A spread of the content of electromagnetic radiation, sorted by
wavelength
- Squiggle Bulb - A CFL with the discharge tube coiled in a spiral or other convoluted
pattern
- Stroboscope Disc - A disc with spaced lines that appear to stand still when the disc
is rotating at the correct speed. Requires lamp to flash at the original power line frequency.
- Sulfur Lamp - An inductive plasma lamp with sulfur as the active ingredient
- Switching Power Supply - Produces wanted voltage using high frequency oscillators,
transformers, and other components
- Visible Light - Electromagnetic energy with a wavelength between 380 nm and 760 nm,
able to stimulate human eyes
- Visible Spectrum - A spread of the content of visible light, sorted by wavelength from
380 nm (violet) to 760 nm (red)
- Volt-Amperes (VA) - The measure of complex power
- Volt-Amperes Reactive (VAR) - The measure of reactive power, or the reactive portion of
complex power
- Watts (W) - The measure of resistive power, the only portion of power on the wires
produced by power generators
- Wavelength - The distance between successive wave crests, measured in nanometers (nm)
for light, and as spectral color
|