AMISH BUGGIES
SPECIAL HAZARD

Why they are different than other vehicles when in traffic.

Amish buggy Most traffic accidents involving Amish buggies result in total destruction of the buggy and often cause severe injury or death for anyone aboard.

There are several factors that make such an accident more dangerous than other kinds of accidents. Here is a list of the special hazards involved and why they are more dangerous than similar factors in other kinds of accidents:


  1. Hazards within traffic:
    1. Hard to see

      - Most Amish buggies are black, necessitated by the Ordnung (Amish law).

      - They move slowly, usually on the shoulder if available.

      - A motorist could mistake it for a motorized vehicle under poor lighting.

      - The night lights are not at the outside edges of the buggy.

    2. Slow moving

      - Usually a buggy cannot go faster than 10 to 15 mph.

      - A buggy will go much slower than 10 to 15 mph when going uphill.

    3. Varying speed

      - When the buggy comes to a hill going up, the horse has to slow down to pull the grade. Speed can drop to human walking speed or slower.

    4. Motion can be erratic

      - The buggy has to dodge potholes and other road irregularities to avoid wheel damage.

      - The horse might go to one side or the other to avoid stepping in a dangerous place

    5. A horse can be spooked, causing the buggy to do unpredictable things

      - The buggy might be pulled ahead at speed, even if it is damaged.

      - The horse might rare up.

      - The buggy might suddenly change direction.

      - The horse might move in a way that overturns the buggy.

  2. Hazardous motorist behavior:
    1. Blowing the horn loud and long to complain about the delay of a slow vehicle blocking traffic

      - This can spook the horse, causing unpredictable results (see above).

      - A spooked horse might run directly in front of the car.

      - The buggy could turn over in front of the car.

      - NOTE: The buggy driver will pull out of the way as soon as he can, to reduce the hazard and let you pass.

    2. Following too close as though that could speed up the buggy

      - If the buggy has to stop or slow down, this can cause an accident.

    3. Speeding over a hill crest or around a curve

      - If a buggy or a tractor is beyond the crest of a hill or around the corner, a collision is quite likely.

    4. Passing too close to the buggy

      - Often the motorist sees the buggy body, but does not see the outboard wheels or the horse. This is especially true at night.

    Remember that ridden animals and animal-drawn vehicles also have the right to use the road.

  3. Hazards of visibility:
    1. Hard to see at night

      - Most Amish buggies are black.

      - Often the horse is a dark color too.

      - The buggies are slow moving, usually on a shoulder.

      - A motorist seeing only the required lights and the Slow-Moving Vehicle sign could mistake it for a motorized vehicle.

    2. The required lights are not at the outside edges of the buggy.

      - The lights are usually on the right and left edges of the buggy body.

      - The wheels project out to the sides about a foot on each side.

      - The wheels project out behind the body by almost the radius of a wheel.

      - The horse is in front of the front lights. Often the horse is a dark color.

      - A motorist thinking the buggy is a slow car can follow too close and hit the back wheels.

      - A motorist thinking the buggy is a slow car can turn or pass in front of the buggy and hit the unseen horse.

    3. A buggy is hard to identify under difficult seeing conditions

      - Fog, glare, and darkness can make it hard to determine that the vehicle is a horse-drawn buggy.

  4. Hazards in the collision:
    1. The first thing on a buggy a vehicle could hit is a wheel or the horse.

      - A collision from behind can damage or destroy one or both back wheels.

      - A sideswipe collision can damage or destroy one or both wheels on one side.

      - A right-angle collision can break all four wheels.

    2. As soon as a wheel is damaged, the entire buggy collapses.

      - The broken wheel can't hold up the buggy, so it falls toward the broken wheel.

      - This may go the other way if the colliding vehicle goes under and holds up part of the buggy.

      - The buggy can collapse in any direction.

      - The buggy body is often destroyed when the buggy collapses.

      - The occupants of the buggy will probably be killed or injured in such a collision.

    3. If the motorist hits the buggy at speed, it can shove the buggy body some distance before stopping.

      - Often this throws the buggy body off the road.

      - In one case, the buggy body and occupant were thrown over a guardrail and down an embankment.

    4. The horse will likely spook in an accident (if it is not injured) injuring the occupants of the buggy even more.

      - The occupants may not be in a condition able to stop or soothe the horse.

      - Possibly nobody else present would have the knowledge of how to stop or soothe the horse.

    5. The buggy body is not usually strong enough to survive an accident intact.

      - The occupants will usually be killed or injured if the buggy body is damaged or thrown.

    6. If the buggy body turns over, it can throw and injure the horse and the occupants.
    7. An interesting fact in many buggy collisions:

      - The surviving parts of the buggy are usually the front axle, shafts, harness parts, and the horse.

      - The front axle often separates from the rest of the buggy at the steering pivot.

One would hope that the bishops of the various parishes would not oppose these safety improvements.

  1. Fixing hazards of visibility:
    1. The lights are not at the actual extremes of the buggy

      - Most Amish buggies are black.

      - Often the horse is a dark color too.

      - The lights are usually on the right and left edges of the front and back of the buggy body.

      - The wheels project out to the sides about a foot on each side.

      - The wheels project out behind the body by almost the radius of a wheel.

      - The horse is in front of the front lights. Often the horse is a dark color.

      - A motorist seeing only the required lights and the Slow Moving Vehicle sign could mistake it for a motorized vehicle.

      - A motorist thinking the buggy is a slow car can follow too close and hit the back wheels because the lights are farther forward.

    2. Put the lights at the actual extremes

      - Make the body of the buggy (or at least the frame) long enough that the lights are farther back than the back wheels.

      - Put a bumper that is wider than the wheels on the back of the longer buggy frame.

      - Put the back lights and the SMV symbol on top of the bumper.

      - If the above is too heavy for the horse, put the lights on metal bars bolted to the buggy body that place the lights where they need to be (as above).

      - Put the front body lights on a similar wide bar at the front of the buggy body.

      - Put a light on the horse's harness on top of the head.

      - Put headlights on the sides of the horsecollar two inches from the horse's body.

      - The lights must be visible from the side of the buggy.

      - Add reflectors to further make the buggy and horse visible.

      - Reflectors at the extreme top edges of the buggy roof would make the buggy more visible over the crest of a hill.

    3. Light-emitting diodes (LEDs) are brighter and have much longer battery life.

      - The lights could be individually powered or part of a wiring harness.

    4. The expanded lighting above can make it easier to identify as a horse-drawn buggy under difficult visibility conditions

      - It is hoped that the bishops understand that these are necessary for safety, and are not intended to decorate the buggy.

  2. Fixing hazards of collision:
    1. Strengthen the buggy

      - Something stronger than wood is needed for the frame.

      - The buggy must remain light enough so the horse can pull it up a hill.

      - Aluminum might be a suitable material.

      - A roll bar is advisable.

    2. Make the back of the buggy crashworthy.

      - Make the body of the buggy (or at least the frame) long enough that the back end is farther back than the back wheels.

      - Put a bumper that is wider than the wheels on the back of the longer buggy frame.

    3. Fasten the seats securely to the frame.

      - Use seat belts secured to the frame.

Amish buggy lights

The suggested lighting and frame changes applied to the buggy: